Skip to main content

The Cake Pull Tradition: When Fortune-Telling Pastry Gets It Spectacularly Wrong

5th Feb 2026

Just came across this Instagram post from a cake maker who's discovered "cake pulls" - apparently it's a southern US tradition that's been flying under the radar up north. The concept is brilliant: hide silver charms attached to ribbons under the bottom cake layer, guests pull them out, and each charm supposedly predicts something about their future. Heart for love, ring for "you're next to get married," clover for good luck, anchor for adventure. Cute, right?

https://www.instagram.com/reel/DUWKPNTDpW7/

Except here's where it gets absolutely hilarious.

Picture this: You're at a wedding or bridal shower, the cake looks gorgeous (and this one genuinely does - proper professional job), everyone's excited about the whole charm-pulling ritual. You reach for your ribbon, give it a tug, and out comes...

The ring charm.

"Congratulations! You're next to get married!"

Lovely sentiment. Really sweet. Except you're already bloody married.

What exactly are you supposed to do with that information? Frame it? Show your spouse and say "Apparently, we need to do this again"? Trade it with someone, like it's a disappointing Monopoly card?

The cake has basically just told a married person that marriage is in their future. It's like getting a fortune cookie that says "You will eat Chinese food" while you're literally sat in a Chinese restaurant with chopsticks in your hand.

The tradition itself is genuinely lovely - there's something quite charming (pun absolutely intended) about these little symbolic moments. But the universe has a wicked sense of timing, doesn't it? Somewhere at that same event, a single person probably pulled the thimble or the anchor while the married guest is stood there clutching a ring like some sort of cosmic administrative cock-up.

Fair play to the baker though - the cake looks spot on. Just maybe add a "terms and conditions apply" disclaimer to that ring charm next time.